eBrandAid Churns Out the 3 Best Butter Substitutes

Posted in Dairy Foods

Our last Label Lesson spread the word about the benefits of real butter.

In addition to being darn tasty, butter comes naturally packaged with many nutrients that can help protect you from chronic disease.

And, the whipped butter varieties taste just as yummy but are lower in calories, fat and cholesterol than regular butter.

Today, we turn the spotlight on butter substitutes.

Sadly, looking for the best picks here was no easy feat. Most of the brands we investigated turned out to be merely “healthy food imposters.”

Sure, they all tout ZERO TRANS FATS, LESS SATURATED FATS and ZERO CHOLESTEROL – and promises of “tastes just like the real thing” – but upon closer inspection…well, read on for the eBrandAid truth about three popular choices.

I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Spread

cantbelieveCalories 80, Fat 6g (2g saturated fat, 0g trans), Cholest. 0g, and Sodium 90mg

INGREDIENTS:  Vegetable Oil Blend (Liquid Soybean Oil, Liquid Canola Oil, Hydrogenated Soybean Oil, Partially Hydrogenated Soybean Oil), Water, Sweet Cream Buttermilk (Adds a Dietarily Insignificant amount of cholesterol), Salt, Soy Lecithin, Vegetable Mono and Diglycerides, Potassium Sorbate (Used to Protect Quality), Citric Acid, Artificial Flavor, Vitamin A Palmitate, Beta Carotene (for Color).

Blue Bonnet Soft Spread

bluebonnetCalories 80, Fat 6g (2g saturated fat, 0g trans), Cholest. 0mg, and Sodium 125mg

INGREDIENTS:  Liquid Soybean Oil, Partially Hydrogenated Soybean Oil, Water, Whey, Salt, Vegetable Mono- and Diglycerides and Soy Lecithin (Emulsifiers), Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate (to Preserve Freshness), Artificial Flavor, Phosphoric Acid (Acidulant), Vitamin A Palmitate, Colored with Beta Carotene (Source of Vitamin A).

Brummel & Brown Spread with Yogurt

brummelCalories 45, Fat 5g (saturated fat 1g, 0 trans fat), Cholest. 0mg, Sodium 90mg

INGREDIENTS: Vegetable Oil Blend (Liquid Soybean Oil and Partially Hydrogenated Soybean Oil), Water, Nonfat Yogurt (Cultured Nonfat Milk), Salt, Gelatin, Vegetable Mono and Diglycerides, Soy Lecithin, (Potassium Sorbate, Calcium Disodium EDTA) used to Protect Quality, Lactic Acid, Artificial Flavor, Vitamin A (Palmitate), Beta Carotene (for Color).

Decoding the fine print

After reading the fine print on the ingredients list of these top-selling “healthy spreads” here’s what We Can’t Believe:

  • They all claim “zero trans fats” on the front label, yet their ingredients lists contain Partially Hydrogenated Soybean Oil – that’s a code term for trans fats. What a scam!
  • “Everything tastes better with Blue Bonnet on it” is a catchy jingle, but can anything really taste better covered with partially hydrogenated soybean oil, potassium sorbate, sodium benzoate and artificial flavors? We think not!
  • Adding yogurt to a spread choked with artery clogging fat doesn’t make it a healthy choice.
  • After tasting this stuff, we can’t believe that anyone can’t seriously believe it’s not butter. These spreads taste NOTHING like butter to us!

Note to self:  Many sneaky food manufacturers still use the trans fat labeling loophole that allows them to claim zero trans fats as long as the per serving amount is less than 0.5 grams.

Reality Check

Okay, in theory, healthy spreads are supposed to be better for you because they’re made from heart-healthy vegetable oils, so they contain way less saturated fat and cholesterol than real butter.

It sure sounds like a better bargain for your health…but not if these butter substitutes contain hidden sources of trans fats and too many hard-to-pronounce additives.

But, if the thought of using the real deal still doesn’t butter your muffin, you’ll be happy to know that our slick sleuths worked extra hard to bring you the goods – as in good spreads that are good for you too!

Best Brands

Earth Balance Margarine Natural Buttery Spread Lactose Free

earthbalanceCalories 100, Fat 11g, Saturated 3.5g, Cholesterol 0mg, Sodium 120mg

INGREDIENTS:  Expeller Pressed Natural Oil Blend (Soybean, Palm fruit, and Canola Seed and Olive), Filtered Water, Pure Salt, Natural Flavor (Derived from Corn, No MSG, No Alcohol, No Gluten), Soy Protein, Soy Lecithin, Lactic Acid (Non-Dairy, Derived from Sugar Beets)




Decoding the fine print: This 100% vegan spread contains 100% expeller-pressed oils and comes with no trans fats (honestly, no trans fats) and no added preservatives.

Olivio Spreadable Butter with Canola & Olive Oil

olivioCalories 80, Fat 10g, Saturated 3.5g, Cholest. 10mg, Sodium 85mg

INGREDIENTS:  Sweet Cream, Canola Oil, Light Olive Oil, Salt, Flaxseed Oil and Natural Flavoring.



Decoding the fine print: This spread combines the best of both worlds – sweet cream plus healthy oils. It’s also low in saturated fats and cholesterol – and contains no trans fat!

Smart Balance Omega Plus™ Buttery Spread

smartbalanceCalories 80, Fat 9g, Saturated fat 2.5g, Cholesterol 0mg, Sodium 90mg

INGREDIENTS:  Natural Oil Blend (Soybean Oil, Palm Oil, Canola Oil, Olive Oil), Water, plant sterols, contains Less Than 2% Of Salt, Whey,  Soybean Lecithin, Potassium Sorbate, Lactic Acid (To Protect Freshness), Natural & Artificial Flavor, Vitamin 3, Calcium Disodium EDTA, Vitamin A Palmitate & Beta-Carotene Color.


Decoding the fine print: This spread gets our SilverMedal Distinction – it’s a good choice, but it’s just not the best. Here’s the skinny: It contains healthy oils, no trans fats, plus the added benefit of natural plant sterols which help support healthy cholesterol levels. But, it falls short of our BestBrands standard because it contains a few preservatives and artificial flavors.

Bottom Line: A healthy spread isn’t healthy if it contains trans fats and enough junk ingredients to make your health…toast!

Remember, when you’re armed with a little eBrandAid know-how, you’re in control at the grocery store.

Tags: , , ,

In Our Opinion: The information contained in the eBrandAid e-newsletters is strictly based on the opinions of the eBrand Doctors. We have created a set of guidelines that we believe will help shoppers to better understand and decode food labels on products found in most grocery stores. Our mission is to help shoppers find the healthier brands that have the least amount of chemicals and other junk ingredients.

Leave a Reply